Both look great. How long will you be in Italia for? For the cooler season, I would go with the right jacket, during the warmer spring time, I would go with the right jacket.
No idea what the weather's like where you're going. Taking both will occupy a lot of luggage space, so check it out on AccuWeather. Rome is going to be 60*+/- 10* for the foreseeable future. I think the pink will travel better.
I love them both but I really love the fur collar. i think it depends entirely on the weather--the pink one look good for warmer days while the fur collar will work well in cooler weather. W/ either one, you'll look great and fit in well w/ other Italia