I think of all three, the red goes best with your skin tone. But I think the quality of the lipstick is the problem, Try cheaper but good quality brands like jordana and nyx. :)
@Caitlin okay i will go to a store or multiple and see what i can find and do. the lip stick that i got were from mac and saphora so ill try a different brand but previous times when i got lipstick they have either been from saphora and/or mac so i guess
The top two don't compliment your skin tone at all. If you go to a Mac counter ask a make up artist what colors they think would go well with you, try them, say thank you and go to the drugstore and find dupes